Ethics Beginner

Stoicism and the things you can control

What is up to us, what is not, and how to tell them apart.

The idea

Epictetus was born a slave in the Roman Empire and became one of the most influential Stoic philosophers. His central insight is captured in the opening of the Enchiridion:

"Some things are up to us and some are not up to us."

What is up to us: our judgements, our desires, our actions — the movements of our own mind. What is not: our bodies, our reputation, our property, outcomes in the world. Stoicism teaches that nearly all suffering comes from treating things outside our control as if they were inside it.

The main positions

Classic Stoicism (Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius)

Virtue is the only genuine good. External things — health, wealth, status — are "preferred indifferents": worth pursuing if easy, but not worth distress when lost.

Strongest objection

This seems too demanding. It is hard to maintain equanimity about everything outside our control, and some external losses seem genuinely bad rather than just "preferred indifferents".

Modern therapeutic Stoicism

Focus on what you can control as a practical technique for reducing anxiety and improving resilience — without necessarily adopting the full Stoic metaphysics.

Strongest objection

Detached from its philosophical basis, this risks becoming a self-help cliché that ignores the genuine importance of some external goods.

Key thinkers

Epictetus
Enchiridion and Discourses. A former slave who argued that freedom is always possible through how we respond to circumstances.
Marcus Aurelius
Meditations. The philosopher-emperor who practised Stoicism as a daily discipline and wrote for himself, not for publication.
Seneca
Letters and essays on Stoic ethics, written for a Roman audience with great rhetorical skill.

Read next

Epistemology · Intermediate Plato's cave, explained without the jargon Prisoners, shadows and the climb into daylight.

Questions about this guide

Common questions